by HallsofIvy » Sat Jul 25, 2020 1:05 pm
I presume you know that the volume of a cone with height, h, and base radius, r, has volume [tex]\frac{\pi}{3}r^2h[/tex]. We are told that the water in the large cone has height (2/3)h
Now, a complication here is that, while we are told that the height of the cone is 'h", we are not told the radius. It doesn't matter as long as we realize the the two "cones", the large cone and the water in it have the same ratio of "height to radius". Calling the radius of the large cone "r", the ratio of height to radius is h/e. Calling the radius of the smaller cone "r*", we have ((2/3)h)/r*= h/r so 1/r*= 3/2r, r*= (2/3)r. That is, the volume of the water is [tex]\frac{\pi}{3}((2/3)h)((2/3)r)^2= (2/3)^3[(\pi/3)hr^2][/tex]. That is, the volume of the water is [tex]\left(\frac{2}{3}\right)^3= \frac{8}{27}[/tex] of the volume of the larger cone.
This is an example of a general principal- area is proportional to the square of a length, volume to the cube. If a solid object is "doubled in size" (so that its length, height, width are doubled) then it surface area is 4 times as great and its volume 8 times as great.
Galileo used this principle to argue that "giants", shaped just like people but, say, 4 times as tall, could not exist. Such a creature would have [tex]4^3= 64[/tex] times the weight but only [tex]4^2= 16[/tex] times the strength (strength of a muscle is proportional to its cross section area). It would collapse under its own weight.